FANDOM

A FANDOM user
  Loading editor
  • Hello, I know my message might sound bold, but we could keep talking about Berserk by email.

    I rarely find someone who can analyze and respond calmly. You and me speak Spanish, so I'd feel more comfortable.

    Likewise, I'd understand if you didn't want to.

      Loading editor
  • Just read manga and watch anime+movie, he uses them ^.^

      Loading editor
    • In order to source anything, one needs to back up any given claim on the matter by stating where exactly (e.g. manga episodes) one can see what you're saying, no matter how obvious it may be. For example, when sourcing the Holy See article, I couldn't find anything that explicitly stated that the Pontiff was its leader :P

      It also involves having a rough knowledge of where to find what you're looking for in order to minimise media juggling. Plus that one page can always slip through the cracks!

        Loading editor
    • I will add this "commander" conversation to this conversation too; There you said about only manga being source when actually there are also anime, movie and games. Latest game has a lot things to confirm you have been worried if they are right. Judeau is a commander to his own unit (he has even an item named "Commander of a Thousand") and in that game's wiki (https://koei.fandom.com/wiki/Judeau) there is a funny sentence: "Like Casca and the others, he is inspired by Griffith to join the Band of the Hawk as the commander to his own unit." As I said earlier everyone who was in that royal party is in a higher ranks (not sure about Rickert since he is a child, but not even impossible since Griffith has a certain sense of humor) and they are also in the important planning conversations with Griffith, they are clearly in higher ranks and it is clear that Casca and Guts are not only commanders. If you are so worried bout these things I recommend you to start reading, watching and playing since you can't believe common sense that tells throughout the story that Judeau is clearly a commander only with how you see him positioned in the story situations and with common knowledge of rankings and positions in these kind of things you can understand he is a commander. Latest confirmation is this latest game "BERSERK and the Band of the Hawkwhere they have clearly written these things and it has gone through Miura's confirmation so it is very good source nowadays if you are worried about these things that are clear with just understanding what happens in Berserk and how Judeau is presented in it =) And to add that "two swords" conversation; they aren't just for show, they are his weapons he uses since we can see him having them in many pictures and sources, even if it wouldn't have been showed (but it has been shown) in the manga or anime, movie or game that he uses them, they are his used weapons, it isn't for a decoration. Have a good day and I hope you think these things through and understand these things since you like to edit wiki so much!

        Loading editor
    • As you can read in the Style Guide, wiki articles cover elements that can be sourced by referencing manga episodes in which said elements appear. It makes sense, as manga is the canon product. That's why a line from the manga in which x (e.g. whether Casca and co. are commanders) is stated is needed to back up or refuse a claim. Of course, one has to be aware that Dark Horse translations might have not conveyed it properly.

      Anything else (such as elements from the video games) that diverges from the manga will go in the "Notes" part. For example, the official guidebook does refer to Judeau, Pippin, Casca and Corkus as unit commanders, but nothing is said about Rickert. Speaking of games, I've never read anything about Miura being involved in the musou game. Now, since this wiki considers Sword of the Berserk (a game that was written and designed by Miura with its original name explicitly including it as a chapter in the Millennium Falcon arc) as non-canon, it's a moot point.

      I do not wish to engage in edit wars, especially when the rules that deal with sourcing any given claim are clear.

        Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
  • How's your opion about Guts in Griffith's eyes before the Esclipe. Do you think what he said to Charllote on the night Guts killed Julius is not applied to Guts :)

      Loading editor
    AzureKesil
    AzureKesil closed this thread because:
    Irrelevant...?
    08:13, February 13, 2020
  • Who are you ? 

      Loading editor
    • View all 16 replies
    • Oh haha

      We have the same taste about gener to watch.

      I really enjoy those type of manga/anime, although they're alittle bit dark,blood,adult, abstract but if we think deeply, they really reflect the world we live with many dark sides, the way we think, what we desire, realed to psychological matters ( I had some troubles transmit my thought :) ). sadly nowaday those type are gradually replaced by other teen oriented type of manga/anime...

        Loading editor
    • Yeah, I know what you mean. Though I prefer fantastic environments, which is why I was attracted to Berserk. When I first watched that PS2 intro, I wondered who the God Hand members (well, I didn't know their name back then) were. Thus, my first Berserk anime experience was that of the 1997 anime Eclipse without knowing how important it was XD

        Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
  • Why? I said it "could be" not "it is"

      Loading editor
    • Hence why it's speculation. As far as I know, only sourced claims are allowed.

        Loading editor
    • All right as you wish. Damnit burocracy

        Loading editor
    • It's not about acting "as I wish", but complying with the rules each wiki has. This wiki is making huge efforts to be seen as a reliable source about all things Berserk, so sticking to such rule is a fully understandable move, even if I may not agree with it.

        Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
  • Please could you give your opinion on what to do about minor characters/ the Minor Characters page on the discussion on my wall?

      Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
  • For the fixes on my Ivaler(i)edit. ^^,

      Loading editor
    • You're welcome! Fixing minor typos is my forte, or at least that's what I want to think.

        Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
  • Please could you offer your opinion on the newest discussion about whether or not we should keep the Minor Characters page?

      Loading editor
  • Hi, welcome to Berserk Wiki! Thanks for your edit to the Guts page.

    Please leave me a message if I can help with anything!

      Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.